• World News
  • Politics
  • Stock
  • Investing
  • Editor’s Pick
Time And Sales Reporter
Editor's PickInvesting

The Right to Control Your Property Is Fundamental

by April 11, 2025
April 11, 2025

Thomas A. Berry and Mike Fox

housing

Property owners in New Braunfels, Texas, have long exercised the fundamental rights to acquire and make use of their property, including the right to make their homes available for rent on a short-term basis. That all changed in 2011 when the city adopted an ordinance banning short-term rentals from all residential areas. The city’s purported justifications were to preserve the “residential character” of neighborhoods and abate nuisances, despite numerous studies showing that short-term rentals don’t produce more nuisances than other property uses. 

In 2020, a coalition of short-term rental owners filed suit alleging that the ordinance violates the US and Texas Constitutions. The city then moved to dismiss—before any evidence being considered—arguing that the district court must accept its bare assertion that short-term rentals cause an unacceptable risk of nuisances. After the district court agreed to dismiss the case, the owners appealed to the Fifth Circuit. Cato filed an amicus brief during that original appeal in 2022, arguing that the district court should have allowed evidence and reviewed it carefully. The Fifth Circuit agreed, sending the case back to the district court. However, after all evidence was admitted, the district court again ruled in favor of the city—readopting the same logic it had relied upon in its first dismissal and failing to meaningfully engage with the record evidence. 

The case is now heading back to the Fifth Circuit a second time, and Cato has once again filed an amicus brief supporting the property owners. In our brief, we explain that property, freedom, and economic liberty are fundamental constitutional rights, deeply rooted in our nation’s history and traditions. Despite this, restrictions on those rights have not been meaningfully scrutinized by modern federal courts. Challenges to such restrictions are subject instead only to highly deferential “rational basis” review. Under this standard, the government wins if it can merely show that it had a “rational basis” for adopting the restriction—a far too lenient test. 

Nevertheless, both the Fifth Circuit and the Texas Supreme Court have invalidated economic restrictions under rational basis review when those restrictions were entirely unsupported by evidence. This shows that it is possible to win a case under rational basis review when it is clear that the government had no legitimate motivation for adopting the regulation. That is the case here. The Fifth Circuit should once again reverse the district court. And, in its opinion, the Fifth Circuit should recognize the unacceptable weakness of current doctrinal protections for property, freedom, and economic liberty.

previous post
When “Fairness” Becomes Censorship: The Push to Regulate Social Media
next post
It’s Tax Season—Five Charts on Who Pays and What’s at Risk

Related Posts

Don Durrett: Gold, Silver Miners to Rip Even...

October 17, 2025

Strategic Entry into Australian Gas Infrastructure Sector

October 17, 2025

AF2 Capital Corp. Enters into Letter of Intent...

October 17, 2025

Convertible Note and Placement

October 17, 2025

Completes Two Pools Gold Acquisition

October 17, 2025

LendingTree founder and CEO Doug Lebda dies in...

October 16, 2025







    Stay updated with the latest news, exclusive offers, and special promotions. Sign up now and be the first to know! As a member, you'll receive curated content, insider tips, and invitations to exclusive events. Don't miss out on being part of something special.


    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.




    Recent Posts

    • SOUTHCOM commander announces sudden retirement amid Trump drug war in Caribbean

      October 17, 2025
    • White House considers cash rewards for Gazans aiding search for slain hostages

      October 17, 2025
    • Ex-National Security Advisor John Bolton indicted with improper handling of classified documents

      October 17, 2025
    • Teen street musician jailed for leading anti-Putin song performance in St. Petersburg: report

      October 17, 2025
    • Erika Kirk shows TPUSA staff Charlie’s Medal of Freedom: ‘You guys are all part of the legacy’

      October 17, 2025
    • About us
    • Contact us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 timeandsalesreporter.com | All Rights Reserved

    Time And Sales Reporter
    • World News
    • Politics
    • Stock
    • Investing
    • Editor’s Pick

    Read alsox

    Amazon taps Xbox co-founder to lead new team...

    May 31, 2025

    Google’s Ad Tech Business Faces Uncertainty After Court...

    April 18, 2025

    Comet share sale and debt repayment

    July 28, 2025